Best Pay-Per-Mile Car Insurance: Save Big If You Barely Drive
You drive your car a handful of times a month. Maybe to the grocery store or a friend’s house. Yet your car insurance bill rivals that of a daily commuter. Frustrating, right? Pay-per-mile car insurance fixes that. You pay a low monthly base rate plus a small fee for each mile driven. It’s a game-changer for low-mileage drivers like remote workers, retirees, or urbanites who walk or bike more than they drive.
The Federal Highway Administration notes the average U.S. driver logs 13,476 miles annually. But many drive far less—under 7,500 miles yearly. For them, traditional insurance overcharges. A 2024 Insurance Information Institute study says pay-per-mile plans can cut costs by up to 40% for low drivers. That’s real money back in your pocket. Let’s explore how this works, who it benefits, and the best providers to consider.
What Is Pay-Per-Mile Car Insurance?
Pay-per-mile car insurance ties your bill to how much you drive. You start with a monthly base rate covering essentials like parked car risks. Then, you pay a few cents per mile driven. Unlike traditional flat-rate policies, which charge the same regardless of use, this model rewards low mileage.
A mile-tracking device or smartphone app logs your trips. Insurers tally miles monthly, adding the per-mile fee to your base. Safe drivers often earn discounts, blending usage-based insurance perks with mileage focus. It’s ideal for those who drive sporadically, ensuring you don’t subsidize high-mileage drivers.
This approach stems from the rise of usage-based insurance, which uses data to tailor costs. If you drive 200 miles a month, your bill reflects that—not a commuter’s 1,500 miles.
How Pay-Per-Mile Insurance Works
Sign up with a provider offering pay-per-mile plans. Choose coverage levels like liability insurance or comprehensive. Most send a plug-in device for your car’s OBD-II port (found under the dashboard). This device tracks miles without monitoring speed or braking in basic plans.
Each month, the device sends data to your insurer, or you upload odometer photos via an app. Your bill combines the base rate with per-mile charges—typically 4–8 cents per mile. For example, 300 miles at 6 cents plus a $30 base equals $48 total.
Apps often show real-time mileage. You can adjust driving to stay under budget. Coverage remains robust, including liability for accidents or extras like roadside help. Setup is quick: plug in the device, sync the app, and drive.
Benefits of Pay-Per-Mile Insurance
This model shines for low-mileage drivers. It’s cost-effective, flexible, and rewards smart habits. Here’s why it stands out:
- Big Savings: Pay only for miles driven. A 2024 NAIC report says low drivers save 20–40% versus traditional plans.
- Eco-Friendly Edge: Less driving cuts emissions. Many insurers promote green benefits.
- Safe Driving Rewards: Mile insurance companies often discount cautious habits.
- Custom Fit: Adjusts to life changes—new job, less commuting, or seasonal travel.
- Transparency: Apps show real-time costs. No surprise bills.
Low mileage correlates with fewer accidents, per the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. You save money and stress less on safer roads.
Top Pay-Per-Mile Car Insurance Companies
Several mile insurance companies excel in pay-per-mile plans. They balance coverage, tracking ease, and savings. Here’s a detailed look at the best.
Nationwide SmartMiles
Nationwide’s SmartMiles program is a top pick. You get a plug-in device on signup. It tracks miles accurately via GPS. Base rates start low, fitting most budgets.
The app sends trip alerts and cost estimates. Users praise fast claims and support. Available in 35 states, including South Carolina. Great for those wanting a trusted name with robust liability insurance options.
Metromile
Metromile pioneered pay-per-mile insurance. Their focus is simplicity: low base rates and competitive per-mile fees (often 5–7 cents). You upload odometer photos monthly or use their device.
Best for urban drivers under 10,000 miles yearly. Strong in states like California and Illinois. Online quotes are quick, and claims process smoothly, per user reviews.
Mile Auto
Mile Auto skips complex tech. Snap monthly odometer photos via their app—no plug-in device required. This suits tech-averse drivers or older cars.
They target low-mileage urbanites with affordable base rates. Growing fast in states like Texas. Clear billing and responsive support make it a solid choice.
Allstate Milewise
Allstate’s Milewise blends pay-per-mile with their full coverage suite. A plug-in device tracks miles precisely. You can bundle liability insurance with collision or roadside help.
Ideal for families or drivers wanting extras. Available in many states, with strong customer ratings for claims. App integration is seamless for monitoring.
USAA SafePilot (Military Only)
USAA’s SafePilot offers pay-per-mile for military members and families. App-based tracking fits busy schedules. No device needed for some plans.
Known for stellar service, USAA keeps base rates low. Eligible drivers enjoy savings and flexibility. Check availability if you qualify.
Compare these mile insurance policies by state, mileage, and coverage needs. Most offer online quotes for easy decisions.
How to Choose the Best Pay-Per-Mile Provider
Picking the right provider starts with your driving habits. Log last year’s miles using odometer records or trip logs. Under 7,500 miles yearly? You’re a prime candidate.
Check if providers operate in your state. South Carolina drivers, for instance, can access Metromile or Nationwide. Get quotes from at least three companies to compare base rates and per-mile fees.
Consider these factors:
- Coverage Options: Ensure liability insurance meets state minimums. Add comprehensive if needed.
- Tracking Method: Prefer a plug-in device or app-based photo uploads? Choose what fits your comfort.
- Customer Support: Read reviews for claims speed and service. Check sites like J.D. Power.
- Discounts: Look for safe driving or multi-policy bonuses.
- State Rules: Verify local laws, as some areas limit usage-based insurance.
Many providers offer trial periods. Test a policy to confirm savings. Switch if it aligns with your budget and driving style.
Understanding Mile Insurance Policies
Mile insurance policies function like standard ones but bill differently. You get core protections:
- Liability Insurance: Covers bodily injury and property damage if you’re at fault.
- Collision: Pays for your car’s repairs after accidents.
- Comprehensive: Handles theft, vandalism, or weather damage.
The difference? Costs scale with miles. Base rates cover fixed risks (e.g., parked car theft). Per-mile fees add 4–8 cents, with caps around 250–300 miles monthly. Exceed that, and rates may adjust slightly.
For example, a $30 base plus 300 miles at 6 cents totals $48. Drive 1,000 miles? That’s $90. Always track to stay low.
Usage-Based Insurance vs. Pay-Per-Mile
Usage-based insurance (UBI) is the broader category. It tracks driving habits—miles, speed, or braking—via apps or devices. Pay-per-mile is a UBI subset, focusing solely on mileage.
Traditional plans charge flat rates, ignoring use. UBI rewards low activity or safe habits. Pay-per-mile suits predictable low drivers best, while broader UBI fits those wanting behavior-based discounts.
Choose pay-per-mile if mileage is your main concern. It’s simpler and often cheaper for under 10,000 miles yearly.
Setting Up and Using a Mile-Tracking Device
Most providers send a plug-in device post-signup. It fits your car’s OBD-II port (under the dashboard or near the steering wheel). Setup takes minutes:
- Plug in the device. It syncs via Bluetooth or cellular.
- Download the provider’s app. Pair with the device.
- Drive normally. The device logs miles passively.
- Check monthly reports. Pay via auto-billing.
No device? Some, like Mile Auto, use odometer photo uploads. Snap a picture monthly, upload, and done. Both methods ensure accurate bills without privacy-invasive tracking (e.g., no speed data in basic plans).
Troubleshooting is rare. If the device fails, contact support for a free replacement. Apps often include FAQs or live chat.
Who Saves Most? Real-Life Examples
Pay-per-mile shines for specific drivers. Let’s look at examples:
- Sarah, Remote Worker (Austin, TX): Drives 250 miles monthly for errands. Switched to Metromile. Cut her bill from $100 to $60 monthly—a 40% drop.
- Mike, Retiree (San Diego, CA): Logs 150 miles monthly for leisure. Nationwide SmartMiles halved his costs to $45 monthly. He enjoys worry-free golf trips.
- Lila, Urban Student (Chicago, IL): Drives 100 miles monthly. Mile Auto’s photo-based plan saves her $500 yearly versus traditional insurance.
A 2024 III study confirms: low-mileage drivers (under 7,500 miles) save $400–$600 annually. Your savings depend on miles and provider rates.
Read More:
Medical Payments Coverage in Car Insurance: Healthcare Maze
Do I Have Gap Insurance? Quick Assessment for Peace of Mind on the Road
Potential Drawbacks and How to Handle Them
Pay-per-mile isn’t perfect. High-mileage drivers (over 12,000 miles yearly) may pay more than with traditional plans. Exceeding monthly caps can raise fees slightly.
Privacy concerns? Devices track miles, not routes. Prefer less tech? Use photo-based plans like Mile Auto. Data stays secure, per insurer privacy policies.
Tips to maximize savings:
- Carpool or Rideshare: Cut miles with friends or apps.
- Plan Trips: Combine errands to reduce driving.
- Maintain Your Car: Good tires and brakes boost safe driving scores.
- Review Bills: Check monthly reports for errors.
In South Carolina, local regulations support usage-based insurance. Check for incentives like eco-driving credits.
State-Specific Availability
Pay-per-mile availability varies. Leading states include:
- California: Metromile and Nationwide dominate. Urban drivers benefit most.
- Illinois: Mile Auto and Allstate Milewise are strong. Chicago loves the model.
- South Carolina: Growing with Metromile entry. Check local quotes.
- Texas and New York: Expanding options. Verify your zip code.
Providers add states yearly. Use online tools to confirm coverage.
Conclusion
Pay-per-mile car insurance transforms how low-mileage drivers pay. You cover a low monthly base rate plus cents per mile. It’s fair, flexible, and perfect for remote workers, retirees, or city dwellers. Top providers like Nationwide, Metromile, and Mile Auto offer easy tracking and robust coverage, including liability insurance.
Don’t overpay for miles you don’t drive. Get quotes from three providers today. Plug in a device or snap a photo, and start saving on your next trip.
FAQs
What’s the Best Pay-Per-Mile Insurance for Low-Mileage Drivers?
Metromile leads for pure mileage focus. Low base rates and 5–7 cents per mile suit drivers under 10,000 miles yearly. Nationwide’s SmartMiles is great for wider coverage options.
How Does a Plug-In Device Work for Mile Insurance Companies?
It plugs into your car’s OBD-II port. Tracks miles via GPS or odometer. Sends data monthly for billing. No speed or route tracking in basic plans.
Does Pay-Per-Mile Include Liability Insurance?
Yes. All plans cover state-required liability for accidents and damage. Add collision or comprehensive for extra protection.
Is Pay-Per-Mile Available in South Carolina?
Yes. Metromile and Nationwide offer plans. Check availability and get local quotes online.
How Do Mile Insurance Policies Differ from Standard Ones?
They charge per mile driven, not a flat rate. Base fees cover fixed risks; per-mile fees add up based on use. Ideal for low drivers.
References:
